Build Your Authentic Executive Presence

Episode 547 | Host: Emilie Aries | Guest: Dr. Alexa Chilcutt

How other people perceive your leadership ability directly impacts your career trajectory, for better or worse.

You’ve likely heard the term “executive presence” before. But for a phrase that most often appears at the end of the sentence, “you need to work on your…”, it lacks an objective definition or a clear path to success.

Dr. Alexa Chilcutt is an expert in just such a phenomenon. She even wrote the book on it: The Presence Principle: Embodying Executive Presence to Lead with Impact, co-authored with her fellow instructor and researcher in executive communication at Johns Hopkins University. Alexa uses an Inform, Equip, and Empower framework to demystify this confusing but vital professional perception management skill once and for all. She was more than happy to get into the weeds of her field with me, so we can all give our executive presence a little (or a large) boost.

What is executive presence?

Leaders consider executive presence extremely important in the workplace. In a survey of 400 CEOs and other C-suiters, 89% said that this quality “directly contributes to career advancement.” Another study, by the Center for Talent Innovation (now Coqual), found that 79%  of senior executives feel a perceived lack of executive presence holds people back.

Despite this, that same study showed 81% of people who were advised to improve their executive presence found the feedback they received contradictory and ambiguous. Basically, people know they need it, but they don’t know how to build it. That’s the gap Alexa strives to bridge.

At its heart, Alexa explains, executive presence is “someone’s ability as a leader to align, engage, influence, and motivate people to action.” In other words, the trait is about other people’s perceptions of you. That’s what makes building executive presence something of a PR project. Luckily for us, Alexa started out in advertising and public relations, so she knows a thing or two about managing your message. 

Your presence must be authentic

Professional women have been told for decades that to get ahead, they should act more like the traditional, predominantly male, archetype for what leaders should be like. But faking “executive traits” you think you’re supposed to have isn’t going to convince anyone for long. That’s good news, but it also means you need to figure out your own authentic secret sauce that will demonstrate how confident, trustworthy, and motivational you are, based on your own unique lived experiences and identities.

Step one, then, is internal: nailing down the authentic strengths that make you a great leader. Step two is external: figuring out how to communicate those strengths to ensure people recognize them in you. 

Initial versus enduring impressions

In her book, Alexa talks about two key factors that weigh into how executive our presence really is: initial and enduring impressions. We know how important that first impression is. It sets the stage for whether someone is even going to give you a chance to progress the relationship. 

But we all know someone (or many someones) with whom we were very impressed at first, only to be disappointed by them in the long run, when all the promise they seemed to exude turned out to be an illusion. That’s where enduring impressions come in. They give you a chance to showcase your values in action. This builds interpersonal integrity, which in turn builds trust. When people trust you, they’ll follow you.

Start showcasing your impact

Alexa understands the tendency to shy away from talking about your achievements at work. This instinct is probably familiar to you, and for most of us, it’s largely rooted in the negative pushback against “bragging” that we’ve internalized all our lives. As women, we’re often taught that drawing attention to ourselves is impolite or unladylike, and encouraged to let our actions “speak” for themselves to be humble about our successes. The problem is, actions don’t speak. 

Alexa learned this lesson the hard way after losing a promising job early in her career because she didn’t share her accomplishments along the way. As a result, the board that might have hired her assumed the organization’s success would have happened with or without her. Determined never to make the same mistake again, she took every opportunity to give detailed reports about her progress and impact to the higher-ups.

If the idea of touting your achievements makes you feel the ick, you aren’t alone. Alexa lays out two reframes that can help.

First, don’t think of it as tooting your own horn. Rather, you’re giving your team or your boss the talking points they need to understand the value of your work, so they can talk about it to shareholders and other decision-makers with the deserved degree of enthusiasm.

Second, don’t share your win; share the impact that win had. If you open with “the company saw a 50% increase in sales this quarter because of our [Project Everyone Knows You Oversaw]” rather than “I completed [This Task],” you’re centering the 1000-foot view. This is a double whammy: it shows you’re both a capable manager and a big-picture thinker.

Common barriers to developing executive presence

In working with mid-level leaders to help them advance in their careers, Alexa has identified three things that consistently hold people back.

  1. So many people at this level of leadership don’t take enough advantage of the seat at the table that they have been offered. When you’re included in larger meetings, it’s essential that you speak up. If you’re worried about just adding noise because you don’t think you have insights to share, ask clarifying questions instead. Expert or not, you were invited for a reason. You have more to contribute than you think.

  2. Many of Alexa’s students take the wrong approach to self-advocacy. As I touched on above, Alexa recommends that when the opportunity to share arises, move away from just reporting the tasks. “My team completed 1, 2, and 3 this month” doesn’t paint a picture of impact and future-thinking the way “Because of our project, the company saw wins 1, 2, and 3 this month” does.

  3. Of course, lots of (female and male) workers struggle with impostor syndrome, which is no stranger to most of us. There is one big indicator of confidence that you actually can fake until you make it. Alexa says, “Someone who is seen as confident is also in control of time.” So often, we want to prove we have every answer, so we leap on questions with rushed intensity. In the end, that works against us. Confident leaders aren’t in a hurry. When you’re asked a question, pause for a few seconds; it makes you look more thoughtful. (Years ago, I interviewed David Allen about time management and his Get Things Done methodology.)

Number three might evoke some understandable irritation. As women, we’re so often expected to be everywhere at once and everything to everyone. It’s maddening to learn that appearing as overwhelmed as we often are could hurt our chances of career advancement. But beyond the appearance of calm, there’s a hard truth here: if you’re overwhelmed, you might need to improve your delegation skills, too.

Alexa points out that we tend to assume our teams are just as overwhelmed as we are and shy away from dumping more on their plates. But often, if we offer a project or a task, one of our direct reports or coworkers will be eager to scoop it up. Instead of thinking of it as “dumping,” think of it as empowering them to have more opportunities to shine. It’s just an added bonus that it lightens our to-do list a little.

A simple step to building your executive presence

Try Alexa’s simple activity to help you identify what you need to work on when it comes to executive presence.

Grab a piece of paper and a pen. Imagine you are polling all the people you work with (direct reports, horizontal coworkers, and superiors). If you asked them for three adjectives they’d use to describe you to someone else, what would those adjectives be?

Now think: At my best, what are the adjectives I want to convey to be the authentic leader I aspire to be? 

Compare those two lists. Where they differ is the gap you need to fill to be a motivating leader that your team wants to follow. From here, you can come up with actions that cultivate and better convey those three goal adjectives.

Exuding virtual presence

Alexa’s tips and insights relate largely to in-person situations, and most people in corporate roles today continue to spend at least part of their time in office. However, more and more of our presence is being built and shared online, so I asked her how we can cultivate better executive presence in the virtual sphere.

She points out that you can tie in your adjectives from the exercise above here, as well. What does someone who exudes those traits look like? So much of how we interpret interactions is non-verbal. It’s up to you to set the stage, and when it comes to Zoom calls, say, that’s you and your background. Alexa recommends structured clothing, something with a collar that creates lines. If you’re not a business formal type, a blazer over a t-shirt is still a great way to add some executive framing. You’ll also want to make sure you have good lighting, a camera angle that’s not up your nose, and a tidy, minimal background.

And what about LinkedIn, yet another place where first impressions can have a huge impact? Alexa encourages people to have a profile photo that’s really them (don’t use AI for this part). It doesn’t have to be a professional headshot, but it should be well-lit and flattering. For your banner image, return to your adjectives again. Does that big background convey what you want? Finally, use those adjectives in your LinkedIn profile to really drive home your cohesive, competent persona.

Alexa has so much more advice and wisdom like this in her book. You can order a discounted copy of The Presence Principle: Embodying Executive Presence to Lead with Impact using this link.

I want to hear about your own executive presence journey! If you’ve been told you lack this quality, how are you tackling that? What tips from this conversation are you most excited to try out? As always, you can email me directly or visit the Courage Community on Facebook or our group on LinkedIn to weigh in.

Related links

Discover even more ways to LEVEL UP your executive presence:

Previous
Previous

Why Adding to My Plate Eased My Burnout

Next
Next

The Hidden Force Keeping Women from Using AI